By Mar­tin Kel­ley. Should armed forces per­son­nel threaten dis­senters by telling them to leave the coun­try? Here’s my pro­posal for an Armed Forces pledge to sup­port dissent.

Yes­ter­day I got an email from Nick Hol­l­i­day, a U.S. Marine serv­ing over­seas:
bq. I am a U.S. Marine assigned to the Diplo­matic Secu­rity Ser­vice in a coun­try I choose not to name… You have no idea why we went into Iraq and like myself, prob­a­bly never will. Do you know why? Because you don’t need to. Because you prob­a­bly wouldn’t under­stand.… Here is an idea. If you hate our Gov­ern­ment and our mil­i­tary and our lead­ers so much, move. Leave. Bet­ter yet, go to Iraq or Afghanistan. Live free and peace­fully. You would last about 5 min­utes. Grow up, shave your beard, sell your Hybrid Toy­ota and be a man. Sup­port your coun­try, pay your taxes and quit whin­ing. You’re pathetic.
I get emails like this every day, of course, but I still can’t help feel­ing sad for Amer­ica. Here’s a intel­li­gent Amer­i­can say­ing that I don’t need to under­stand the rea­sons for war, that I wouldn’t under­stand them. What kind of sur­ren­der to blind author­ity is this? I could imag­ine this argu­ment in Medieval europe or in the dark­est days of iron-fisted Soviet rule. But the United States is built on the very idea that the com­mon man and woman do know enough to run the coun­try. We don’t need to mil­i­tary strong­man like Hitler to decide our best inter­ests for us. We don’t need a reli­gious Aya­tol­lah to tell us how to live. We don’t need stat­ues of Sad­dam Hus­sein on every street cor­ner to remind us of the absolute author­ity of the gov­ern­ment. Our lead­ers are civil­ians just like us and we can (and must!) crit­i­cize and double-guess them. Over two hun­dred years ago, Amer­ica broke the mold of tyran­ni­cal gov­ern­ments to bet that the give-and-take of free speech and democ­racy would pro­duce the most free coun­try the world had ever seen. So far it has.
But the last part of Holliday’s email is a threat. An armed rep­re­sen­ta­tive of my gov­ern­ment is ask­ing me to leave the coun­try because he dis­likes my polit­i­cal views. Some­one who has promised to defend the Con­sti­tu­tion with his life thinks noth­ing of send­ing a threat­en­ing email to a dis­senter who is express­ing his free speech. I get these emails every day. I know they’re just a way for Armed Forces per­son­nel to vent off. But these threats are inap­pro­pri­ate. They are not an honor to the uni­form.
I under­stand that many U.S. Armed Forces per­son­nel like Nick Hol­l­i­day might not like what I have to say. But if “Amer­ica” is some­thing spe­cial worth fight­ing for, it’s not because here an ultra-patriot can shoot their mouths off (ultra-patriots the world over are sup­ported by their gov­ern­ments). What’s spe­cial about Amer­ica is that here our Marines promise to pro­tect even the dis­senters. Some U.S. mil­i­tary per­son­nel sta­tioned in Iraq recently com­plained about the war to the press. This was roundly crit­i­cized as going against the mil­i­tary code to serve stead­fast but silently, to sow dis­gruntle­ment or chal­lenge civil­ian author­ity. I think it’s time for mil­i­tary per­son­nel to pledge not to chal­lenge Amer­i­can dissenter’s right to free speech. They should honor their coun­try and renew their promise to defend the right to free speech.
I have writ­ten the fol­low­ing pledge for Nick Hol­l­i­day and his col­leagues in uni­form.
h4. Pledge to Sup­port Right of Dis­sent
*As a mem­ber of the Armed Forces I sup­port free­dom of livestyle*
* I sup­port Amer­i­cans’ right to eat what they want to eat, drive the car they want to drive and keep their facial hair in what­ever style they choose.
*As a mem­ber of the Armed Forces I will never tell some­one to move to Iraq/Afghanistan/Current enemy*
* I’m proud that dis­senters can live safely in Amer­ica with­out fear of reprisal. I may not agree with their argu­ments but I trust that any out­ra­geous ide­olo­gies will be debunked in the polit­i­cal arena with­out mil­i­tary inter­ven­tion or threat of expul­sion.
*As a mem­ber of the Armed Forces, I encour­age American’s active polit­i­cal par­tic­i­pa­tion*
* I sup­port American’s right to ask ques­tions. I under­stand that in a democ­racy, national strength comes from an informed and empow­ered electorate.