Claire Flourish examines a Quaker anti-trans campaign

March 11, 2025

Fas­ci­nat­ing and dis­turb­ing account of an out­spo­ken Quak­er* UK anti-trans activist who has start­ed a video pod­cast inter­view­ing promi­nent Friends. Most of the episodes have noth­ing to do with gen­der and sex­u­al­i­ty but some do. 

The aster­isk up is there because the pod­cast­er appar­ent­ly renounced their mem­ber­ship in the Soci­ety of Friends when Britain Year­ly Meet­ing passed a minute on trans inclu­sion. I appre­ci­ate some­one dis­agree­ing with a year­ly meet­ing res­o­lu­tion and even stay­ing in the fold despite the oppo­si­tion. But when an affirm­ing minute that doesn’t actu­al­ly affect you (just your ide­ol­o­gy) is such a bur­den that you leave… well then the ques­tion is why you would put such effort into a pod­cast of your ex-religion. it doesn’t seem like a project borne in good faith. 

Claire does a great job bring­ing the receipts and explain­ing the con­text (the details of which I haven’t been following). 

Nilay Patel on why blogs are still great

March 11, 2025

The Verge’s Decoder turns the table on its host, Nilay Patel, to talk about blogs. I often appre­ci­ate Patel’s take on the mod­ern web. And while I run a few web­sites, I appre­ci­ate his joke that The Verge is “the last web­site on earth.” There was a cer­tain kind of web­site back in the day that you’d vis­it direct­ly to see what they were say­ing. Their reporters were fun­ny and snarky and opin­ion­at­ed and even when I dis­agreed with their take, I was usu­al­ly glad I had tak­en the time to read it. There’s a few indi­vid­ual blog­gers like that left, folks like Jason Kot­tke and John Gru­ber, but few sites still like The Verge, in my opin­ion. So much of the con­ver­sa­tion today hap­pens on social media, where it’s frac­tured (Mastodon? Face­book? Threads? Bluesky?) and ephemeral.

About a year ago, The Verge went for a more old-school blog­ging mod­el, based on appeal­ing to peo­ple vis­it­ing the site direct­ly rather than Google algo­rithms. I’m glad they did that. 

There’s also good stuff in her about brands: “But you know what? All the celebri­ties still want to be on the cov­er of mag­a­zines. They want the val­i­da­tion that the big brand, the insti­tu­tion, can pro­vide. And there’s a rea­son for that because the brand stands for more than just an indi­vid­ual opin­ion — or at least at its best it does.” I think that’s true for my work with Friends Jour­nal. Any­one can write some­thing and post it any­where, yet there still seems to be a yearn­ing for a place that’s still a common-ground water­ing hole, a conversation-starter.

Reading: George Fox – the First Quaker Socialist?

March 11, 2025

Gra­ham Tay­lor with a well-cited arti­cle on the proto-socialism of ear­ly Friends. There’s a bit of anachro­nis­tic think­ing going on here, which he admits to. But it’s also the case that a lot of Quak­er his­to­ry is viewed through the lens of lat­er Quak­ers and often ignores what was hap­pen­ing out­side of Quak­erism at the time. This can lead to bad his­to­ries. I’m not sure I buy some of Tay­lor’s argu­ments but it’s a good exer­cise and Fox cer­tain­ly did talk about eco­nom­ics as part of his call for justice.

Where Do We Find Our Hope?

March 11, 2025

Decem­ber’s Friends Jour­nal is online and looks at Spir­i­tu­al Opti­mism vs. Spir­i­tu­al Pessimism. 

> Has there ever been an age in human his­to­ry in which we could be pure­ly opti­mistic or pure­ly pes­simistic? Quak­er founder George Fox wrote that his min­istry arose “when all my hopes in [preach­ers and expe­ri­enced peo­ple] were gone, so that I had noth­ing out­ward­ly to help me, nor could tell what to do.” He famous­ly found inspi­ra­tion, guid­ance, and courage in “one, even Christ Jesus,” who could speak to his con­di­tion. What keeps us going today in a world always ready to implode or blossom?