Quaker Theology in Five Acts

Friends Gen­er­al Con­fer­ence, the asso­ci­a­tion of Lib­er­al Quak­ers in North Amer­i­ca, has dis­trib­uted a new (at least new to me) copy of the famous Quak­er Vocal Min­istry Flow­chart. One could do a doc­tor­al the­sis com­par­ing the edits in sub­se­quent ver­sions of this and the the­ol­o­gy they assume or omit. Here’s one ques­tion’s evolution:

  • 1991: Mes­sage input from within? 1
  • 2014 : Do you per­ceive this mes­sage as a gift from the Holy Spirit?2
  • 2015 : I feel led to minister? 3
  • 2019: Is this mes­sage from the Holy Spirt and not from intel­lect or ego? 4
  • 2026: Is this mes­sage from beyond your­self, beyond intel­lect or ego? 5

The whole idea of a flow­chart is very com­put­er pro­gram­mat­ic so it seems fit­ting that the ear­li­est ver­sion describes the impulse to min­is­ter as a “mes­sage input.” The British ver­sion is just about as no-nonsense, ask­ing if we “feel led to min­is­ter.” There’s appar­ent­ly a ver­sion from the very ubiq­ui­tous Quak­er pas­tor Stan Thorn­berg in the July/August 1997 issue of the now-defunct Quak­er Life mag­a­zine (any­one have a copy they could scan?). The 2014 and 2019 ver­sions ask us to con­sid­er whether an incom­ing mes­sage is “from the Holy Spir­it” but the new ver­sion only asks if it’s “from beyond” (to be fair, this is clos­er to the 1991 input version).

I’ve said before I think these charts are less-than-helpful in a mod­ern reli­gious soci­ety where min­istry is often sparse and cliched. I don’t think Quak­er min­istry needs to be this hard. I love the sto­ries of the old Quietist-era min­is­ters. One was said to just rise to his feel when prompt­ed by the Holy Spir­it, with absolute­ly no idea what he was going to say. For him ris­ing was an act of faith that God would spon­ta­neous­ly pro­vide him with the words to speak. I’m sure pas­sages like Matthew 10​:19 – 20 were an inspiration:

But when they deliv­er you up, take no thought how or what ye shall speak: for it shall be giv­en you in that same hour what ye shall speak. For it is not ye that speak, but the Spir­it of your Father which speaketh in you.

For him the chart was: Do I feel led by the Holy Spir­it to min­is­ter? –> Go for it.

In many Quak­er cir­cles it’s not cool to go back to the Qui­etist min­is­ters or point to the Bible pas­sages that shaped our cul­ture or even appar­ent­ly to talk as if we might expect the Holy Spir­it to be involved in Friends’ min­istry. So inputs and mes­sages from beyond it is. In the com­ments, tell me how you think this ques­tion will be posed cir­ca 2032 when a new ver­sion would be ready to drop? The blog should still be here and com­ments have time­stamps so you’ll have brag­ging rights if you guess it correctly!

  1. Friend­ly Woman
  2. Chest­nut Hill Meet­ing, Philadelphia
  3. Zélie Gross, UK
  4. FGC, Bar­ry Cross­no & Brent Bill
  5. FGC